Should I Include My Personal Essay If It Is Optional? And Why Not Add a Unicorn to Your Resume While You're At It?

When faced with the decision of whether to include a personal essay in an application where it is optional, many students find themselves at a crossroads. The question is not just about whether to submit the essay, but also about understanding the implications of this choice on their overall application. This article explores various perspectives to help you make an informed decision.

The Case for Including the Essay

1. Showcasing Your Unique Voice

A personal essay is a golden opportunity to let your personality shine through. It allows you to present aspects of your character and experiences that aren’t captured in grades or test scores. Admissions officers often appreciate essays that reveal a candidate’s unique perspective and voice.

2. Demonstrating Commitment

Submitting an optional essay can signal to the admissions committee that you are genuinely interested in their institution. It shows that you are willing to go the extra mile, which can be a positive indicator of your dedication and enthusiasm.

3. Addressing Potential Weaknesses

If there are any gaps or weaknesses in your application, such as a lower GPA or a lack of extracurricular activities, a well-crafted essay can provide context. It allows you to explain any extenuating circumstances and highlight how you’ve overcome challenges.

4. Standing Out from the Crowd

In a pool of applicants with similar academic credentials, a compelling personal essay can be the differentiating factor. It can make your application memorable and help you stand out in a competitive field.

The Case Against Including the Essay

1. Risk of Mediocrity

If your essay is not exceptionally strong, it could do more harm than good. A poorly written or generic essay might detract from the rest of your application. It’s crucial to ensure that your essay adds value rather than serving as a filler.

2. Time Constraints

Writing a high-quality essay requires a significant investment of time and effort. If you’re already stretched thin with other application components, it might be more strategic to focus on those rather than rushing an optional essay.

3. Potential for Overkill

Sometimes, less is more. If your application is already robust and comprehensive, adding an optional essay might be unnecessary. It could come across as overzealous or redundant, especially if it doesn’t provide new insights.

4. Admissions Fatigue

Admissions officers read hundreds, if not thousands, of essays. If your essay doesn’t grab their attention immediately, it might get lost in the shuffle. The risk of it being skimmed or overlooked is a valid concern.

Middle Ground: Strategic Inclusion

1. Tailoring the Essay

If you decide to include the essay, make sure it is tailored to the specific institution and program. Generic essays are easily spotted and can be a turn-off. Research the school’s values and culture, and reflect these in your writing.

2. Seeking Feedback

Before submitting, seek feedback from teachers, mentors, or peers. An outside perspective can help you identify areas for improvement and ensure that your essay is polished and impactful.

3. Quality Over Quantity

Focus on depth rather than breadth. A concise, well-argued essay is more effective than a lengthy, meandering one. Make every word count and ensure that your narrative is clear and compelling.

4. Aligning with Your Application

Ensure that your essay complements the rest of your application. It should add a new dimension to your profile, rather than reiterating information that is already evident elsewhere.

FAQs

1. What if I don’t have a compelling story to tell?

Not everyone has a dramatic or unique life story, and that’s okay. Focus on authenticity and reflect on experiences that have shaped you, no matter how small they may seem.

2. Can I reuse an essay from another application?

While it might be tempting, it’s generally better to tailor each essay to the specific institution. Admissions officers can often tell when an essay is generic or recycled.

3. How long should an optional essay be?

Follow the guidelines provided by the institution. If no length is specified, aim for a concise essay that is long enough to make your point but short enough to maintain the reader’s interest.

4. What if I’m not a strong writer?

If writing isn’t your forte, consider seeking help from a mentor or using online resources to improve your skills. Alternatively, focus on other strengths in your application.

5. Is it better to submit an optional essay or not?

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Consider your unique circumstances, the strength of your essay, and the overall context of your application before making a decision.

In conclusion, the decision to include an optional personal essay is a nuanced one that depends on various factors. By carefully weighing the pros and cons and considering your individual situation, you can make a choice that enhances your application and showcases your best self.